The Pantry
Olive oils and balsamics worth reaching for every night.
Welcome to Olive Tree Marketplace
Thoughtfully chosen.
Meant to be enjoyed.
Premium pantry favorites, home essentials, thoughtful gifts, and everyday inspiration.
Ways to explore
What are you looking for?
Shop what you came for — or let us help you find something worth gathering around.
Ways to shop
Come in the way that suits you
-
-
Home Fragrance
Candles, melts and sprays that make a house feel gathered.
-
Coffee & Comfort
Coffee, tea and the warm things that go with them.
-
Cook & Gather
Start with what you are making — we will bring the rest.
-
Gifts for Every Occasion
For her, for him, for the host — chosen, not searched.
-
Celebrate the Season
Fall at OTM: gather, cook, cozy, give.
Featured favorites
Loved at our table, made for yours
A short, deliberate list — the bottles and blends we keep reaching for as the season turns.
Simply Elegant
Four scents for a season worth staying in
Hand-poured soy, made in Casey, Illinois. Pumpkin Patch, Snuggle Weather, Acorn Lane and Autumn Cider — each a 16 oz candle, and most with a matching 6 oz wax melt.
The four scents
-
Warm & Woodsy
Acorn Lane
-
Warm & Spiced
Autumn Cider
-
Warm & Indulgent
Pumpkin Patch
-
Warm & Cozy
Snuggle Weather
From the OTM kitchen
Cook something worth gathering for
Every recipe connects to the bottles that make it — shop the recipe, not the aisle.
-
Italian Herb Focaccia
A generous, dimpled focaccia with a crisp bottom and an open crumb, made with Italian herb olive oil from the bowl to the pan.
- 3 hr 30 min
- Medium
Made with Italian Herb - Infused Olive Oil
Shop the recipe — Italian Herb Focaccia -
Crispy Roasted Garlic Parmesan Potatoes
Roasted potatoes with a shattering crust and a soft middle, tossed in roasted garlic olive oil twice: once before the oven and once after.
- 50 min
- Easy
Made with Roasted Garlic - Infused Olive Oil
Shop the recipe — Crispy Roasted Garlic Parmesan Potatoes -
Sheet-Pan Italian Chicken & Vegetables
One pan, one oven, dinner in forty minutes: boneless chicken and summer vegetables roasted together in sundried tomato and parmesan olive oil.
- 40 min
- Easy
Made with Sundried Tomato Garlic Parmesan - Infused Olive Oil
Shop the recipe — Sheet-Pan Italian Chicken & Vegetables -
Sundried Tomato Parmesan Crostini
The appetizer for people arriving in ten minutes: toasted bread, whipped ricotta and a spoonful of sundried tomato oil.
- 20 min
- Easy
Made with Sundried Tomato Garlic Parmesan - Infused Olive Oil
Shop the recipe — Sundried Tomato Parmesan Crostini
Why OTM
Good things, carefully chosen
Made with intention
Every product earns its place before it earns a shelf.
Carefully chosen
Tasted, tested and loved by us before it reaches your table.
Rooted in Casey, Illinois
A small-town storefront with a long table and an open door.
Made to gather
Everything here exists to bring people around something good.
Visit Casey
Come see us in Casey, Illinois
The storefront is the heart of OTM — a place to taste the oils, smell the candles, and stay a while. If you are near Casey, the door is open.
Custom Solutions
Gifts and goods, made yours
Corporate gifting, private label, and custom orders — built around what you need and who it is for.
Wholesale
Stock your shelves with OTM
Retailers: bring the OTM table to your store. Keystone-friendly wholesale with a partner who answers the phone.
Join the Table
There is always room at this table
Recipes worth cooking, new arrivals worth knowing, and the seasonal goings-on at OTM — sent occasionally, and only when worth your while.
- Recipes
- New products
- Seasonal inspiration
- OTM happenings
- Special offers